How to Write a Book Review: After Derrida and Barthes

Deconstructing the Text: A Derridean and Barthesian Approach

Jacques Derrida and Roland Barthes, two influential thinkers, radically changed how we view texts. Their ideas of deconstruction and the "death of the author" offer a fresh lens for book reviews

By using Derrida and Barthes' ideas, you can make your book reviews more interesting and connect better with your audience. Start by seeing that a text can have many different meanings. Instead of saying it's "good" or "bad," explore its different parts.

Engage with questions and ideas that readers might like. Notice specific parts of the text that make people think differently and discuss these views in your review.

Deconstructing the Text: A Derridean Perspective

Derrida's deconstruction shows that texts are complex and have many meanings. Instead of just summarizing a book, readers can explore its hidden layers for a richer understanding.

As a reviewer, this method encourages you to dig deeper into the text's assumptions, problems, and contradictions. Challenge what the text seems to say and what it might imply beneath the surface. When reviewing a book, consider the following:

Hidden Contradictions: Are there any hidden problems or conflicts within the text? Do these problems go against what the author meant to say?

Opposites: Does the text rely on opposites (like good vs. evil or nature vs. culture)? How can these opposites be changed or challenged?

Central Idea: Does the text focus on one main idea? How can this main idea be challenged by looking at the text in a new way

The Reader's Power: A Barthesian Perspective

Barthes said that the author is dead. It's the reader who decides what a book means. This means reviews should focus more on the reader's experience. When writing a review, think about how the book makes readers feel. Discuss the book's themes, emotions, and connections. This will make your review more relevant and powerful

Sensory Experience: How does the text engage your senses? What emotions or sensations does it evoke?

Intertextuality: How does the text relate to other texts or cultural references? How does this intertextuality shape your understanding of the book?

The Reader's Role: How does the text invite the reader to participate in its creation? What role does the reader play in shaping the meaning of the text?

Combining Derridean and Barthesian perspectives

How does the text's underlying structures (Derrida) interact with the reader's subjective experience (Barthes)?

How does the text's deconstruction challenge or reinforce its intended meaning?

How does the reader's interpretation of the text contribute to its overall significance?

Sample Book Review Structure

Introduction: Briefly summarize the book's main themes and arguments.

Analysis by Deconstruction: Identify key contradictions, binary oppositions, or instances of a central idea within the text. Analyze how these elements challenge the author's intended meaning.

Analysis of the Reader's Experience: Discuss the text's sensory qualities, intertextual references, and the reader's role in shaping its meaning.

Conclusion: Synthesize your findings and offer an overall assessment of the book's significance.

Page Pitch

Following these models and examples of excellent writing, pitch your personal essay or send your memoir narrative. Write now, and share and recognize the value of your story. Your legacy lives on in this story.